UK Home Office revises reconsideration rules for modern-slavery cases after High Court ruling

UK Home Office revises reconsideration rules for modern-slavery cases after High Court ruling

On 18 September 2026, the Home Office updated two linked sets of guidance governing modern-slavery cases: the statutory guidance for the National Referral Mechanism and the caseworker guidance on Temporary Permission to Stay for Victims of Human Trafficking or Slavery. The change is legally significant because it removes the previous blanket approach under which people facing removal to countries that are parties to both the Council of Europe Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings and the European Convention on Human Rights could be excluded from reconsideration procedures. The new guidance instead introduces a more individualised assessment and, while a wider review is continuing, allows certain reconsideration requests submitted outside the ordinary 30-day time limit to be examined.

The immediate legal background is R (AYA and others) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] EWHC 1742 (Admin), handed down by the High Court on 10 July 2026. The case concerned an amendment made in September 2025 to modern-slavery guidance which removed access to reconsideration for people whom the Home Office intended to remove to an ECAT and ECHR signatory state, including France under the UK–France returns arrangements. Mr Justice Sheldon held that the amendment was unlawful because it weakened the effectiveness of the system for identifying victims and prevented relevant later evidence from being considered. The Court emphasised that judicial review is not a substitute for an administrative reconsideration capable of assessing new material on its merits.

The distinction between the two procedures is important. Under the National Referral Mechanism (NRM), a potential victim may receive a Reasonable Grounds decision and, later, a Conclusive Grounds decision. Reconsideration concerns whether those identification decisions should be reopened. Separately, a confirmed victim may be considered for Temporary Permission to Stay (VTS) under section 65 of the Nationality and Borders Act 2022 and Appendix VTS to the Immigration Rules. A positive trafficking decision does not automatically produce immigration leave: the person must also satisfy the separate statutory and Immigration Rules criteria for temporary permission. The September update therefore affects both victim-identification procedures and, through separate guidance, reconsideration of immigration-permission decisions.

For negative Reasonable Grounds or Conclusive Grounds decisions, the Home Office says that the reconsideration policy is currently under review. Pending that review, Competent Authorities may consider a request made after the 30-day limit where there is a clear and obvious error in the original decision, or where genuinely new evidence is produced together with an explanation of the exceptional circumstances that prevented earlier submission. The evidence must be capable, when read with the material already considered, of indicating that the person may be a victim of modern slavery. This is an interim administrative policy rather than a new statutory right of appeal, but it expands the circumstances in which a late request can still be examined.

The revised VTS guidance adopts a different but related structure. Where a person with a Temporary Permission to Stay decision is eligible for removal, the relevant Competent Authority must assess the individual circumstances before deciding whether the reconsideration policy should apply or be disapplied. The non-exhaustive factors include the timing of the NRM claim, whether trafficking indicators emerged only after removal action had begun, whether the person previously had an opportunity to disclose exploitation, access to legal advice or First Responders, and any explanation for delayed disclosure. If reconsideration is allowed, the request must normally be made within 30 calendar days of the decision letter or before the scheduled removal date, whichever comes first. If the policy is disapplied, new information relating to trafficking needs, an investigation or prosecution, or an alleged failure to follow published guidance must still be submitted as soon as possible for consideration.

The practical importance of reconsideration is demonstrated by the Home Office’s own data. In the first quarter of 2026, the Competent Authorities received 538 reconsideration requests, including 284 relating to Reasonable Grounds decisions and 253 relating to Conclusive Grounds decisions. The High Court in AYA also examined earlier figures showing that a substantial proportion of reconsidered negative decisions resulted in positive outcomes. Those figures do not establish that every original decision was defective, because reconsideration frequently involves evidence that was not previously available, but they do show that the review stage performs a material corrective function in the identification system.

The United Kingdom’s framework is built on section 49 of the Modern Slavery Act 2015, the Nationality and Borders Act 2022, the Immigration Rules and the United Kingdom’s obligations under ECAT and the ECHR. Italy uses a different institutional model. Article 18 of Legislative Decree 286/1998 provides a specific residence-protection mechanism for foreign nationals exposed to serious violence or exploitation and connected risks, linked to programmes of assistance and social integration. It is not a direct equivalent of the British NRM: the Italian system does not divide victim identification into Reasonable Grounds and Conclusive Grounds stages followed by a separate VTS route. The comparison nevertheless highlights the same structural problem faced by both systems: victim identification and immigration status are related questions, but they are not legally identical and require distinct, reviewable decisions.

Sources: Home Office, “Modern slavery: how to identify and support victims”, updated 18 September 2026; Home Office, “Temporary permission to stay: considerations for victims of human trafficking or slavery”, version 11.0, 18 September 2026; R (AYA and others) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] EWHC 1742 (Admin); Nationality and Borders Act 2022, section 65; Immigration Rules, Appendix Temporary Permission to Stay for Victims of Human Trafficking or Slavery; Legislative Decree 25 July 1998, no. 286, Article 18.

Avv. Fabio Loscerbo;
Avvocato Cassazionista;
Iscritto nel Registro dei rappresentanti di interessi della Camera dei deputati in materia di Immigrazione;
Lobbista registrato presso il Registro per la Trasparenza dell’Unione europea n. 280782895721-36 in materia di Migrazione e Asilo;
ORCID: 0009-0004-7030-0428;
Articolo redatto con l’ausilio di strumenti di AI, sotto la direzione, revisione e responsabilità editoriale dell’autore.

Commenti

Lascia un commento

Altri articoli