A government can bring greater order to migration without increasing the number of people it removes. That sounds
counterintuitive only if deportations have become the main measure of political resolve. Integrazione o ReImmigrazione, the Italian proposal for a continuous system of migration governance, begins with a different objective: an individual should enter through a lawful and credible project, undertake defined responsibilities, and have genuine integration recognised over time. An individual return is a possible outcome only where the law permits it. The project is a proposed reform, not an immigration regime already enacted in Italy or Britain. Its most demanding implication is easily overlooked: a state that successfully supports and verifies integration may have less occasion to contemplate return. That is not a promise about future figures. It is a change in what public policy sets out to achieve and how political claims should be tested.
The foundational address of 10 October 2026 insists upon the order of the two terms in the name: integration comes first; ReImmigrazione follows only as an individually lawful possibility. The address criticises both a labour-market view of the migrant as a vacancy to fill and
identitarian remigration approaches that make demographic origin central. Rather than ask which inherited groups ought to leave, the framework asks what an actual person did during lawful residence and what legal consequences may follow. This difference changes the unit of political accountability. A successful application cannot be inferred from a surname, a national origin, a tally of removals or even the existence of a job contract. It must be traced through the admission decision, opportunities available, responsibilities undertaken and legally relevant conduct. The basic architecture is therefore a theory of the years after admission, not a campaign to produce departures.
Consider two lawful outcomes. One resident fulfils applicable conditions, develops Italian-language ability, works or follows another legally relevant pathway to autonomy, respects binding rules and qualifies, under the relevant legislation, for greater security of residence. The proper outcome is recognition of that achievement. Another resident lacks a lawful basis to remain after the applicable process and protections have been considered. Where a valid return decision can legally and practically be executed, the state must be capable of acting upon it. The two cases require different decisions, and the project cannot be evaluated by adding one to the other. A system that celebrates the second outcome while ignoring the first has mistaken an enforcement instrument for its overall purpose. Equally, a system that celebrates regularisation while disregarding final enforceable decisions would fail its own claim to govern the whole migration journey. Integration and lawful return belong to the same architecture without becoming interchangeable political trophies.
This is why the number of departures, considered alone, is a poor explanation of institutional performance. A departure may be voluntary, the result of a final lawful removal decision, or part of an entirely different movement that says little about the person’s earlier integration. A rise in removals could reflect better execution of valid decisions, the clearing of old cases or a deterioration in initial admission and integration policy; a decline could reflect more successful integration, administrative paralysis or a change in the eligible population. None of those conclusions follows from the count
itself. An earlier British-language article of 1 November 2026 separated voluntary departure from failed integration. The further question here is political: a government should not be able to present every exit as evidence of success while remaining silent about whether those entitled to stay have built stable lives under the common law.
The reform’s concrete mechanism is a personal and continuing record rather than a retrospective impression. Its proposed development of Italy’s existing Integration Agreement would bring together the person’s entry project and the subsequent evidence relevant to work, language and respect for applicable rules. Those three dimensions are meant to be assessed in context, not turned into automatic penalties. Genuine unemployment may have causes other than refusal; a wage packet may coexist with proven breaches of binding duties. Such distinctions are not administrative indulgences. They allow the state to say both when someone has met the conditions of a stage and when a failure is individually attributable. The proposed single framework for progressively secure residence would then make achievement consequential instead of endlessly reopening the same question. None of this is an existing universal Italian residence test; the scope, proof, consequences and remedies would require legislation.
The hardest objection is that success cannot simply be defined as fewer returns. A government could reduce removals by ignoring unlawful residence, diluting requirements or failing to carry out final decisions. That would be no demonstration of successful integration. The answer is to reject deportation numbers as a solitary measure, not to discard the enforceability of immigration law. A credible reform must distinguish a person who has met binding conditions from one who demonstrably refuses an accessible and lawful obligation, and both from someone whose non-compliance was beyond their control. It must also know whether an adverse decision was legally justified and capable of execution. Public confidence requires that the obligations be knowable beforehand, that the evidence can be challenged, and that a lawful favourable decision is acknowledged as seriously as a lawful unfavourable one. Otherwise ‘integration’ risks becoming either an empty promise or permanent probation.
Legal status sets limits which political indicators cannot override. Italian citizens, including those with immigrant parents, are not candidates for immigration return on account of ancestry or an assessment of cultural attachment. For non-citizens, failure on one proposed indicator cannot itself create a removal power. Italian constitutional rights, applicable Union law, international protection, private and family life, individual reasoning and effective remedies continue to matter. Article 19 of the EU Charter prohibits collective expulsion and certain removals exposing people to grave harm, while Article 5 of Directive 2008/115/EC requires attention to children, family life, health and non-refoulement in its field of application. The United Kingdom has a separate immigration regime and is not subject to that Directive. These distinctions do not make return illegitimate; they specify when a state can legitimately invoke it.
This article extends the 16 November 2026 explanation of why ReImmigrazione starts with
integration rather than ethnic selection and the 18 November analysis of how an Integration Agreement should recognise completion. Those articles explained the order of the model and the individual’s possible outcome. The new argument concerns the government’s own claim to success. If the primary objective is integration, a public authority must be able to explain not only which lawful return decisions it has executed, but also which lawful pathways have reached recognised stability and why. More removals do not, by themselves, prove stronger government; fewer do not prove greater justice. The politically meaningful achievement is a system in which each outcome follows from defined duties, individual evidence and enforceable law. ReImmigrazione makes sense only as one possible consequence of that larger task, never as the number the state is trying to maximise.
Avv. Fabio Loscerbo
Lawyer authorised to practise before the Italian Court of Cassation
Registered in the Italian Chamber of Deputies’ Register of Interest Representatives in the field of Immigration
Lobbyist registered in the European Union Transparency Register No. 280782895721-36 in the field of Migration and Asylum
ORCID: 0009-0004-7030-0428
This article was prepared with the assistance of AI tools, under the author’s direction, review and editorial responsibility.
Lascia un commento