ReImmigrazione Starts With Integration, Not Ethnic Selection

Two expressions that sound similar can conceal fundamentally different political tests. In European debate, “remigration” is not the name of one settled programme: some speakers mean enforcing existing return decisions against people without permission to stay, while certain identitarian proposals go further and treat demographic or cultural origin as the problem to be reversed. The
“Integrazione o ReImmigrazione” Paradigm, developed in Fabio Loscerbo’s conference address of 10 October 2026, begins at the opposite end of the process: integration is the purpose, and an individual return is one legally constrained possible outcome, not the political objective. This is a proposed reform of Italy’s migration system, not a law currently in force. The distinction becomes meaningful only when we follow how the proposed decisions would actually be made.

The first test is legal status, not ancestry. A citizen and a foreign resident do not stand in the same legal position: citizenship is a status carrying its own rights, whereas a foreign national’s residence is governed by the conditions lawfully attached to the applicable permission and by overriding protections. Having immigrant parents, retaining a minority faith or looking culturally different does not turn a citizen into someone who can be treated as an expellable foreigner. Nor can a foreign resident be judged by a presumption about a nationality or community. The Paradigm insists on an individual trajectory: what the person has done, which obligations legally apply, and what has actually been established. Its difference from identity-based proposals lies not in a slogan about kindness or severity, but in refusing to substitute a collective category for an assessable personal case.

The trajectory is meant to start before entry. For labour migration, the October address proposes replacing the assumption that the employer initiates the immigration project with an application presented personally by the would-be migrant to the Italian state, supported by a credible plan and, where appropriate, a prospective job. This would require legislative reform; Italy’s present employer-led labour admission arrangements are not thereby abolished. A job remains important, but a worker is not merely a vacancy to be filled, still less an object belonging to a sponsoring firm. Personal initiative matters because the same person who seeks admission must be able to understand the obligations attached to a future stay. This makes the individual a participant in public law from the outset, rather than treating integration as a separate social programme discovered years after arrival.

After lawful entry, the proposed method examines three dimensions together: work, Italian language and respect for the rules. Employment can demonstrate autonomy but cannot, alone, establish civic integration; unemployment following a genuine attempt to participate does not erase the whole history. Language allows an individual to engage with schools, employers and public authorities without perpetual dependence on intermediaries. Respect for the rules refers to conduct and legally identifiable duties, not an imposed political opinion, religious conversion or abandonment of family traditions. The reform would require people to take their
responsibilities seriously, while ensuring that the obligations are clear, relevant and practically attainable. A person’s protected disagreement with government policy is not evidence of failed integration. The relevant political boundary is between respecting a common legal order and being required to think exactly like the cultural majority.

This evaluation would need an intelligible legal instrument. Italy already has an Integration Agreement, introduced through Article 4-bis of Legislative Decree No. 286/1998 and regulated by Presidential Decree No. 179/2011 for the categories to which it applies. It is not an invention of the Paradigm, and its existing credit-based rules must not be confused with the reform being discussed. The proposal is to develop it into a continuing account of an individual’s integration trajectory: verified learning, work, relevant responsibilities and documented fulfilment of applicable commitments. Evidence should be capable of being checked and challenged, rather than becoming a vague judgment on personal character. The Agreement would connect the original immigration project with a reasoned assessment over time instead of allowing a signature or the mere passage of years to stand in for substantive integration.

The decisive outcome is not designed to be an endless probation. Successful integration should lead to increasing legal stability, within the rules governing the particular immigration status. The October address envisages, as a further reform, a “permesso unico di permanenza”: a unified conception of residence whose degree of security would evolve with a person’s lawful trajectory. This is distinct from the European Union’s single permit for residence and work, and it cannot sweep away the separate legal foundations of refugee protection, family life or other protected statuses. Indeed, people granted international protection possess rights that cannot be cancelled by an administrative score. Seen in this way, the project is not a machine for discovering candidates for departure. It is also an explicit promise that verified participation can count towards a coherent route to lasting lawful residence.

What, then, does “ReImmigrazione” mean? Not a collective order, not a penalty for belonging to the wrong cultural group, and not removal automatically following one missed indicator. It means that the state could consider a lawful individual return only where a legal basis actually permits it, after the relevant facts, responsibilities, private and family circumstances and available remedies have been assessed. The European framework supplies concrete
boundaries: Article 19 of the EU Charter prohibits collective expulsions and removals exposing people to specified grave risks when the Charter applies; the Council of Europe’s explanation of the Convention likewise identifies protection against serious ill-treatment and the relevance of private and family life. Citizenship, protection obligations and judicial scrutiny are not secondary exceptions to be worked around. They are part of the legal meaning of any enforceable decision.

A serious objection deserves to be addressed. Nations have histories, languages and traditions, and governments may legitimately debate how these are transmitted. Why should belonging be discussed solely in legal terms? It should not: civic education, shared institutions and participation in public life all have cultural significance. But a cultural ideal is not by itself a legal power to classify people by descent. The analysis of 21 October 2026 on national belonging and identitarian
remigration
drew that boundary; the present explanation adds the proposed sequence that makes it operational: personal admission, knowable duties, evidence over time, recognition of success, and only then a legally permissible individual decision if the statutory conditions arise. Integration is the intended result; return is a conditional possibility. That ordering is what gives “Integrazione o ReImmigrazione” its distinct political and legal identity.

Avv. Fabio Loscerbo

Lawyer admitted to practise before the Italian Court of Cassation

Registered in the Italian Chamber of Deputies’ Register of Interest Representatives in the field of Immigration

Registered lobbyist in the European Union Transparency Register No. 280782895721-36 in the field of Migration and Asylum

ORCID: 0009-0004-7030-0428

This article was prepared with the assistance of AI tools, under the author’s editorial direction, review and responsibility.

Commenti

Lascia un commento

Altri articoli