An immigration application is not merely a request to fill a vacancy. It asks a country to authorise the beginning of a
relationship that may last for decades. Yet a work-based entry system can describe that relationship almost entirely through an employer’s need for labour. The employer has a vacancy; the state processes a request; the prospective migrant is named as the person who will perform the work. The ReImmigrazione approach asks a different question: who should present and take responsibility for the migration project itself? In the broader “Integrazione o
ReImmigrazione” framework, integration is the objective, while an individual return is only a possible outcome where the law permits it. That distinction concerns civic responsibility, not ancestry, ethnicity or an obligation to adopt the majority’s cultural
identity.
The point is not an abstract description of all visas. Italy’s existing employer-led procedures for many forms of employed migration illustrate a particular institutional choice. The Ministry of Labour’s explanation of the 2026–2028 flow programme, dated 16 October 2025, identifies sectors, quotas and applications made by employers. Its 1 October 2026 guidance for the 2027 cycle confirms the continuing use of entry quotas and the employer-facing nulla osta procedure. Other lawful entry routes have different rules. In this work-entry setting, however, the private demand for labour normally precedes the public assessment of the applicant’s future place in society. A genuine job offer is important evidence of a viable plan, but it is not itself an account of the person’s responsibilities over the years that follow.
The original proposal is set out in the interventions of 11 September 2026 and, more explicitly, 10 October 2026. For the relevant labour-entry route, the foreign applicant would personally put forward a credible project of entry and integration to the Italian state, potentially accompanied by a verifiable promise of employment. The employer would remain
responsible for substantiating the offer; the state would retain authority to decide admission under legally defined criteria; the applicant would openly take responsibility for the project being presented. The lectures also contemplate an initial, approximately two-year period of conditional residence with continuing assessment. These are proposals requiring legislation, not procedures already available under the present system. Nor would an applicant-led procedure entitle every person who files an application to enter.
A crucial distinction makes this approach more than a change of signature on a form. There are two different moments of judgment: a credible intention before entry and proven conduct after entry. Before admission, a person can describe a realistic plan, available qualifications, preparedness to learn Italian and willingness to comply with applicable laws. No state can honestly certify years of successful integration that have not yet happened. After arrival, the question changes: has that person actually worked where reasonably possible, made use of accessible language learning and respected obligations defined by law? An initial proposal should therefore be a commitment capable of later examination, not a prediction presented as fact. This guards against turning a policy of individual responsibility into an arbitrary pre-entry cultural test, while keeping the applicant’s commitments central.
This difference matters when work and residence cease to move together. Consider an applicant whose promised job disappears before the employment relationship begins. A failed contract may require a fresh legal assessment of the person’s position; it does not, by itself, prove a deliberate refusal to integrate. Conversely, a secure employment contract does not establish that its holder fulfils every civic or legal obligation. In the proposed framework, work, language and respect for rules are examined together across time, with the cause of any failure taken seriously. The subject of the assessment is the person’s documented trajectory, not the nationality of an occupational group, an employer’s commercial judgment or a collective reputation. The same principle also recognises that citizens and non-citizens occupy different legal positions: a citizen’s right to remain is not subject to an immigrant residence review.
There is a substantial objection. If applicants initiate work migration themselves, states could be flooded with speculative projects, recruiters might sell fictitious promises, and a worker could be asked to shoulder costs that ought to belong to a business. These are not peripheral worries. A defensible reform would require independent verification of jobs, transparent criteria, scrutiny of intermediaries, fair procedures, reviewable decisions and meaningful protection against exploitation. The October intervention discusses a possible contribution towards language and civic training, but such a proposal would need explicit legislation and careful assessment of affordability and equal treatment; it cannot simply be imposed as a condition under current law. The point is to make the applicant a responsible legal actor without converting responsibility into an unregulated market for entry permissions.
A further constraint distinguishes governance from an unconditional power to remove. Conditional residence cannot override the legal protection of refugees, applicable European Union guarantees, respect for family and private life or the prohibition on returning someone to a serious risk of persecution or prohibited treatment. Nor could an employer’s withdrawal automatically produce an expulsion. After a lawful, individual assessment, a positive trajectory may support consolidation of status according to the applicable law or a future reform; a proven and legally relevant refusal may carry only consequences that legislation permits, with access to judicial protection. ReImmigrazione, in this model, describes a legally regulated individual return where possible, not a scheme of ethnic selection and not a penalty automatically attached to one missed benchmark.
A 10 November 2026 article on ReImmigrazione.com, “Decreto flussi: il datore presenta la domanda, il lavoratore rischia l’irregolarità”, examined the imbalance between an employer’s initial request and the worker’s exposure when the promised job fails. This contribution carries the argument one step further for readers new to the model. It separates the applicant’s ex ante ownership of a credible project from the state’s ex post assessment of actual integration. Without that separation, a reform might simply move paperwork from the boss to the migrant while preserving the mistaken assumption that a job offer predicts civic belonging. The central political choice is broader: whether a country regards migration primarily as the purchase of labour, or as the beginning of an individual, legally governed relationship whose outcomes must be assessed over time.
Avv. Fabio Loscerbo
Attorney admitted to practise before the Italian Court of Cassation
Registered in the Italian Chamber of Deputies Register of Interest Representatives in the field of Immigration
Registered lobbyist in the European Union Transparency Register No. 280782895721-36 in the field of Migration and Asylum
ORCID: 0009-0004-7030-0428
This article was prepared with the assistance of AI tools under the author’s editorial direction, review and responsibility.
Lascia un commento