Migration Needs Legal Subjects, Not Private Gatekeepers

A job offer may be genuine, a family may be supportive and a community association may provide valuable help. None can live an immigrant’s civic life on that person’s behalf. This is the starting point for a distinctive element of Integrazione o
ReImmigrazione
, the Italian proposal to govern migration through an individual pathway rather than a series of decisions made about an anonymous worker or a collective group. Its intended result is integration: a person enters under lawful conditions, encounters real opportunities, undertakes legally defined responsibilities and builds a record of conduct that may support more secure residence. An individual return, where legally possible, is another potential result rather than the purpose of the system. For readers encountering the proposal for the first time, the point is not that intermediaries are inherently suspect. It is that the person concerned must remain the subject of the legal relationship with the state. A sponsor can substantiate a job, but cannot certify an entire person’s
belonging.

The framework’s foundational address of 10 October 2026 makes that principle concrete. For Italy’s employer-led labour-admission route it proposes an immigration project submitted personally by the prospective migrant, potentially supported by a verified offer of work. The employer would still substantiate the job; the public authority would still decide admission; the applicant would openly take responsibility for the project presented. The address also envisages an initial,
approximately two-year period of conditional residence followed by assessments of work, Italian-language acquisition and respect for the rules. These are proposals requiring legislative change, not procedures already available under Italian law. A promising plan, moreover, cannot prove that integration has already occurred: the proposed model distinguishes intention before entry from conduct after arrival. Its political point is to separate the person who makes a commitment from the private party who supplies one piece of evidence about that commitment.

The British experience illustrates the distinction without becoming the subject of the proposal. The UK Skilled Worker route relies upon licensed employer sponsorship, yet the migrant personally applies for permission and remains a person with rights and duties, not the employer’s possession. Official Home Office guidance on the loss of a sponsor licence explains that a sponsored worker’s permission may be curtailed, normally to 60 days or the remaining leave if shorter, with the possibility of a fresh application under applicable rules. Those are consequences of a particular immigration route, not a finding that the worker has deliberately rejected civic integration. A sponsor may lose its licence for reasons outside an employee’s control; alternatively, an individual may knowingly breach legal obligations irrespective of the employer’s conduct. A future integration model must be able to distinguish the two. Losing a job is not necessarily abandoning one’s responsibilities, while possessing a contract cannot excuse every personal breach.

The question of whose voice counts reaches beyond employment. A relative, an intermediary or a voluntary association may help someone navigate a new society. Assistance becomes politically troubling when a private actor claims to determine which public rights that individual may exercise. The October address concluded with a discussion of private religiously informed arbitration in Padua, expressly acknowledging that arbitration can be lawful and religious liberty is protected. A later article of 15 November 2026 examined a public disagreement over
representation and the common legal order. Neither episode proves wrongdoing by a religious community; no religious group should be treated as a single political actor. The lasting point is that affiliation must not deprive anyone of independent access to the law. British arbitration law itself recognises both private dispute resolution and judicial limits: section 68 of the Arbitration Act 1996 permits challenges based on specified serious irregularities, including public-policy concerns. This is not a ban on private agreement; it shows why consent and public safeguards have to coexist.

One new institutional principle follows: no substitute responsibility. Public authorities should receive relevant evidence from employers, educators, relatives and lawful associations, but neither transfer an individual’s duties to those actors nor make their approval the test of residence. Within the proposed Italian system, a continuing integration record would show which commitments were undertaken, what legally relevant opportunities existed, what the person actually did and whether an apparent failure was within their control. Someone who develops language skills through a legitimate alternative route may have satisfied a requirement without attending an organisation’s preferred course. A person who deliberately refuses an independently binding and accessible obligation may have a different case to answer. Equally, the migrant whose sponsor closes, or someone resisting coercion within a private relationship, should not automatically be judged unintegrated because another actor withdraws support. The assessment concerns provable individual conduct under knowable rules, not ancestry, religious affiliation, political loyalty or the endorsement of a favoured intermediary.

There is a substantial objection: modern migration systems cannot operate without intermediaries. Employers must prove vacancies, professional advisers explain complex rules, families provide care and community groups build trust that government offices cannot
manufacture. If every applicant had to negotiate each step alone, personal responsibility could become a slogan concealing
vulnerability. An applicant-led system might also attract speculative projects or fraudulent recruiters. The answer is not to abolish sponsorship, advice, mediation or family assistance. It is to identify the boundary between offering evidence and exercising a private veto over another adult’s legal future. Verifying employers, scrutinising dishonest intermediaries, maintaining accessible information and providing procedural help would remain essential. Personal
accountability should make assertions testable, not make the applicant bear the consequences of a sponsor’s fraud. A serious model of integration must expect individual effort while keeping the individual able to answer public authorities in their own right.

Legal limits are indispensable. In Italy, the proposed
restructuring would need legislation and must operate alongside constitutional rights, applicable European Union rules, international protection, respect for private and family life and effective judicial remedies. A citizen, including one whose parents migrated, does not become a removable foreign national because an employer or community leader questions their cultural attachment. For a non-citizen, job loss, an unsuccessful assessment or disagreement with an association supplies no independent power of expulsion. Any adverse residence or return decision requires a lawful basis, individual reasoning, proportionality, protection against refoulement where relevant and access to the remedies provided by law. Britain has a distinct immigration system and is not governed by the EU Return Directive. These differences matter: the proposal is a framework for Italian political and legislative reform, not a rule currently binding British officials or an off-the-shelf replacement for every existing residence category.

This contribution deliberately continues two previously developed arguments rather than reproducing either. “ReImmigrazione Would Shift Labor Migration From Employers to Applicants”, published on 18 November 2026, examined why a prospective migrant should initiate the Italian labour-migration project. The 15 November discussion of communal representation raised a different question about who may speak for a group. Their common implication is the new argument here: it is inconsistent to demand individual civic responsibility while allowing the person to disappear behind successive private gatekeepers. This is the difference between reducing migrants to economic inputs, assigning them inherited group identities and treating them as accountable legal subjects.
Integration is an achievement within the shared legal order, not a certificate issued by a sponsor, family or association. When the law calls for a decision about residence or an individually permissible return, it must be about the person whose life and legal position are at stake.

Avv. Fabio Loscerbo

Lawyer authorised to practise before the Italian Court of Cassation

Registered in the Italian Chamber of Deputies’ Register of Interest Representatives in the field of Immigration

Lobbyist registered in the European Union Transparency Register No. 280782895721-36 in the field of Migration and Asylum

ORCID: 0009-0004-7030-0428

This article was prepared with the assistance of AI tools, under the author’s direction, review and editorial responsibility.

Commenti

Lascia un commento

Altri articoli